Monthly Archives: September 2008

Not with a Bang but a Whimper: The Politics and Culture of Decline

Ivan R. Dee has just published the newest collection of City Journal essays by Theodore Dalrymple. The book is now available for purchase at Amazon and, I presume, your own preferred outlet.

Not with a Bang but a Whimper collects 19 essays published between 2004 and 2008 and includes many of his most discussed essays from that time, such as “What the New Atheists Don’t See” and “The Gift of Language”. We will be reviewing and summarizing the book in due time. For now, the summary from the book jacket is reproduced below. And why not take this opportunity to buy a print subscription to the publication that made this all possible: City Journal, one of the best and most beautiful magazines in America.

“No writer today is more adept and incisive than Theodore Dalrymple in exploring the state of our culture and the ideas that are changing our ways of life. His brilliant new collection of writings follows on the extraordinary success of his earlier books, Life at the Bottom and Our Culture, What’s Left of It.

In Not with a Bang But a Whimper, he takes the measure of our cultural decline, noting that our current age seems exceptional in the peculiarity of its unease: “Never in human history have people lived such long and pain-free lives; never have so many people, and so high a proportion of people, had so much freedom to choose how to live, what goals to pursue, and how to divert themselves. On the other hand, never have so many people felt anxious and depressed, and resorted to pills to ease their distress. Mankind has labored long and hard to produce a cornucopia for itself, only to discover that the cornucopia does not bring the happiness expected, but only a different kind of anxiety.”

Mr. Dalrymple’s special attention is to the British experience–its bureaucratic muddle, oppressive welfare mentality, and aimless young–all produced by people and programs in pursuit of democracy and freedom. He shows how terrorism and the growing numbers of Muslim minorities have changed public life in Britain and elsewhere. Also in the book are Mr. Dalrymple’s trenchant observations on artists and ideologues, and on the treatment of criminals and the mentally disturbed, his area of medical interest.

The collapse of confidence that many people experience is here stringently articulated by one of our keenest social observers.”

Lessons of the long-distance runner

Dalrymple’s essay for the September 2008 edition of The New Criterion is available online.



“Of course, any civilized criminal justice system has always made room for extenuating circumstances and even for complete legal excuses, such as self-defense or duress… But with the rise of mass-education, a different kind of extenuation and exculpation was propagated and became popular, sapping the certainty that crime was justly to be repressed: that of the criminal as a member of a class of unfortunates ex officio, as it were. From being a bad man, the criminal became the victim of social conditions, among which were the unjust arrangements of society as a whole, and in particular the division of property.

“…Literary works helped to bring about the change of sensibility. Among them (but of course it is impossible to estimate the size of its actual effect) was a short story, first published in 1959, and subsequently made into a film, The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner, by Alan Sillitoe.”

Read the full article

A pinch of salts

Dalrymple’s weekly essay for the British Medical Journal is now available online. These short and rather whimsical essays, touching lightly on medical issues, hit the web every Wednesday. This week’s version discusses his grandmother’s use of smelling salts.

$4 purchase required or $82 for one-year unlimited access to the entire website. His essays older than one year are free. See his BMJ links on the left of this page.

Childhood’s End

Dalrymple’s essay “Childhood’s End” from the Summer 2008 issue of City Journal is available online. The essay analyzes the effect of British welfare policy on childhood using the recent cases of Scarlett Keeling and Shannon Matthews as illustration.


“A system of perverse incentives in a culture of undiscriminating materialism, where the main freedom is freedom from legal, financial, ethical, or social consequences, makes childhood in Britain a torment both for many of those who live it and those who observe it. Yet the British government will do anything but address the problem…”


Read the full article

Welcome

Welcome to the Skeptical Doctor blog.

This blog and its parent website are dedicated to tracking and discussing the work and ideas of social commentator Theodore Dalrymple (real name: Anthony Daniels). The blog will serve as an aggregator so that readers have one place to find and discuss all of the latest essays, books and speeches by the man many call the greatest essayist and social commentator since Orwell. Stay tuned for upcoming posts.

To learn more about the life and work of Theodore Dalrymple, please visit the rest of the Skeptical Doctor website. And please take note that this website and blog is not officially affiliated with the writer and that all opinions expressed here (other than direct quotes of Dalrymple himself, of course) belong to the owners and readers of the website and not to Theodore Dalrymple.