Monthly Archives: September 2011

Peake, Prunesquallor, and Pye

Dalrymple’s August 24th BMJ column (subscription required) takes a look at the doctors and medical themes in Mervyn Peake’s Gormenghast trilogy, and describes Peake’s personal medical difficulties:
Peake’s own medical history was tragic in the extreme. During the war he had a couple of breakdowns, and did once consult a Harley Street specialist, an experience that might have been the inspiration for the Harley Street episode in Mr Pye. In his 40s, Peake began to develop symptoms of Parkinson’s disease, and then dementia. Of great charm and good humour, an accomplished draughtsman and painter, a poet and novelist, he spent the last few years of his life in institutions, unable to write, draw, or speak. (He was subjected to both electroconvulsive therapy and surgery that proved useless or worse.) His wife’s memoir, A World Away, published in 1970, is almost too painful to read.
The manner in which Peake’s doctor at the National Hospital, Queen Square, London, breaks the news of the diagnosis to Mrs Peake is an object lesson in medical insensitivity. Mrs Peake asks to meet him but is told that he is too busy at the moment; perhaps he might be able to see her on his way out if she waits in the entrance hall for him. There, in the middle of the busy hallway, he says to her, “Your husband has premature senility.” Peake was 46; she was 39.
She addresses a postscript of her memoir to Peake, describing a visit to him before his death, when he is completely immobilised by the disease: “We sit silently, and then you are restless. You want to move and cannot. You want to speak and cannot, and the silence no longer has peace in it.” Then: “When I leave you, I say ‘Goodbye,’ but goodbye was said many years ago, before we knew we were saying it.”
I have made a resolution never to complain again, but I know that I shall not keep it.

Postponing grief

In the August 17th British Medical Journal (subscription required), Dalrymple profiles American author Peter De Vries:
It often seemed to me during my clinical career that some people were called upon (by what, or by whom?) to bear more suffering and loss than was their fair share, or more than could be explained by anything that they, or indeed anyone else, had done. Tragedy followed them around like an obedient dog; mostly they bore it unprotestingly. They made me feel guilty because I was in the habit of complaining so vociferously about the minor inconveniences of life.
The American writer Peter De Vries (1910–1993) was in general known for his comic novels and for his wit—he once said that he enjoyed being a writer, except for the paperwork. But one of his novels, The Blood of the Lamb, published in 1961, was bleak and tragic—and autobiographical.
De Vries was born of Dutch Calvinist stock to whom (as he later put it) everything was forbidden except heaven. In the novel, his narrator-protagonist’s older brother, a medical student, dies of pneumonia; a girlfriend dies of tuberculosis; his father goes mad and dies in an asylum; his wife commits suicide; and his daughter dies aged 12 of acute leukaemia. Quite a lot of this happened, more or less; and though De Vries was famously antireligious, it is clear that he was still wrestling with his own religious upbringing 50 years after his birth.

The Meaning of Pyongyang

In New English Review Dalrymple disputes the thesis of The Cleanest Race: How the North Koreans See Themselves – and Why It Matters by B. R. Myers, namely that the North Korean dictatorship owes more to fascist imperial Japan than Marx. In doing so, he gets into the difficult and murky distinctions between fascism and communism.
There are some countries that, once visited, retain a disproportionate hold on your imagination. Among them, for me at least, are Haiti and Liberia, two small states that are known to the world at large principally for their political, and sometimes for their natural, catastrophes. They are marginal from the point of view of the world economy, I need hardly say, and yet their history has something about it that makes it seem significant beyond itself. No one, I think, can study the early history of either country without being moved by it; and just as the biography of a single person can also be a portrait of an age, so the history of an otherwise insignificant country can tell us something important about the human predicament as a whole, for example our tendency to turn liberation into a new form of servitude.
North Korea is another country that, once visited, is not easily forgotten. Its hold on the imagination, however, has nothing of affection in it, as does that of Haiti or Liberia. This absence of affection is no reflection upon the Korean people, but rather upon the political system that reigns there. Spontaneous contact with Koreans is precisely what the regime attempts at all costs to prevent, and succeeds to an extent unique even for the communist, or formerly communist, world. Compared with North Korea, Hoxha’s Albania was a free country. In short, North Korea has all the fascination of sheer horror.

Underrated: Theodore Dalrymple


Britain’s Standpoint Magazine has a regular feature wherein they declare well-known intellectuals to be either overrated or underrated, and they have just turned their attentions to Dalrymple.

Jonathan Foreman is effusive in his praise, calling TD “one of Britain’s most incisive, courageous, knowledgeable and clear-eyed public intellectuals” and “arguably, our greatest living essayist”. His comments often echo those in 
our essay on Dalrymple’s importance: “He brings to his observations a wisdom gained from extensive travel, wide and deep reading, and having worked for long periods in places that most middle-class readers and commentators know only at second-hand.”

One of the aspects of Dalrymple’s life and work that we have tried to emphasize here, and that we thought was perhaps underappreciated by even his strongest admirers, was the almost absurd breadth of his experience — and indeed, the singular personality that lead him to seek out that experience. It is good to see others making the same discovery.

Since the riots, we have noticed that Dalrymple’s public profile has grown as commentators increasingly reference his work. Hopefully, he won’t be underrated much longer.

FSM Interviews Dalrymple


An American organization called Family Security Matters has just interviewed Dalrymple about his new book Anything Goes, a collection of his New English Review essays between 2005 and 2009.

The interview is interesting, especially as it includes discussions of Dalrymple’s use of different pseudonyms, his history with the
New English Review, his childhood and his appearance (or lack thereof) in the media.

Read it
here.

Points of View

Dalrymple writes in the new edition of the New Criterion about how a visit to a photographic exhibition in Arles has caused him to discover, for the first time, the power and profundity of photography:


What a fool I have been all these years not to appreciate the power of photography to act as a template for thought and reflection! How many other such idiocies have I been prey to? I fear it might be many. Now I even find myself preparing a book of photographs, to convey something that cannot be conveyed in any other way, at any rate not so economically or powerfully, and perhaps not at all.

Read it here (purchase required)



Dalrymple took many photographs during his extensive travels earlier in life (see for example the front and back covers of Sweet Waist of America). Might we see a new facet of his career?