Pope Francis Should Seek Clarity on Moral Responsibility

At the Library of Law and Liberty, Dalrymple criticizes a recent speech by Pope Francis in which the Pope blames the West for the drowning deaths of Africans migrating across the Mediterranean to Europe.  The refugees deserve our compassion, says Dalrymple, but by blaming the West for their deaths, the Pope elevates sentimentality and spiritual pride above reason:

By elevating feeling over thought, by making compassion the measure of all things, the Pope was able to evade the complexities of the situation, in effect indulging in one of the characteristic vices of our time, moral exhibitionism, which is the espousal of generous sentiment without the pain of having to think of the costs to other people of the implied (but unstated) morally-appropriate policy. This imprecision allowed him to evade the vexed question as to exactly how many of the suffering of Africa, and elsewhere, Europe was supposed to admit and subsidize (and by Europe I mean, of course, the European taxpayer, who might have problems of his own). I was reminded of a discussion in my French family in which one brother-in-law complained to another of the ungenerous attitude of the French state towards immigrants from the Third World. ‘Well,’ said the other, ‘you have room enough. Why don’t you take ten Malians?’ To this there was no reply except that it was a low blow: though to me it seemed a perfectly reasonable response.

Read the rest here

One thought on “Pope Francis Should Seek Clarity on Moral Responsibility

  1. Jaxon

    Dalrymple has said of Virginia Woolf

    “As for the fabled influence of women on men, Mrs. Woolf will have none of it. She writes that it is so “beneath our contempt” that “many of us would prefer to call ourselves prostitutes simply and to take our stand openly under the lamps of Piccadilly Circus rather than use it.” ”

    In Shakespeare’s Pericles of Tyre the virtuous Marina is sold into a brothel (a place that in ethos has much in common with Dalrymple’s description of the Bloomsbury group)
    Bawd –
    “Boult, take you the marks of her, the colour of her
    hair, complexion, height, age, with warrant of her
    virginity; and cry ‘He that will give most shall
    have her first.’ Such a maidenhead were no cheap
    thing, if men were as they have been. Get this done
    as I command you.”

    Marina’s fabled virtue is held so cheap in the rich nations that it is nigh impossible to see how the prospects of the wretched of this Earth will be anything but hostage to this tragedy, this depravity.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *